About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

2021 Actual Probs. Econ. & L. 1 (2021)

handle is hein.journals/apel2021 and id is 1 raw text is: AKTYAlbHbIE  P3IEv    30HOMHKH H fPABA      oM     21o
IDOl: 10.21202/1993-047X.2021.1

DOI: 10.21202/APEL.1993-047X
M3AaeTcs c sHBaps 2007 roga, nepHOAM4HOCTb H3AaHHR - 4 pa3a B roA
PEAAK4MIOHHAH KOJ1J1ErII
rnaBHble pegaKTopbl:
6EKeeB 1. 1., AOKTOp IopMHAMeCKMX HayK, npO4eCCOp, 3aCj1y*eHHbN IOpCT Pecny6MKM TaTapCTaH, nepBbI npopeKTop,
npopeKTOp 0 Hay4HON pa60Te Ka3aHCKOFo MHHOBaI4MOHHOF0 YHMBepCOTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpRCOBa (M3Vf) (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwSI)
KneNHep r. E., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, npO4 eCCOp, LleH-KOppeCnOHgeHT PAH, 3aMeCTMTe/Jb Hay4HOF0 pyKOBOAMTe/
[4eHTpaIbHOF0 3KoHoMMKO-MaTeMaTMLIeCKo0 MHCTMTYTa PoccMcKoN anageMM HaYK (r. MOCKBa, PoccMR)
TwXOMwpOB K). A., AOKTOp IopMHAMeCKMX HayK, npO eccop MHCTMTyTa 3aKOHogaTe/bCa H CpaBHMTe/IbHOF0 npaBOBegeHMA
npM fpaBMTe/IbCTBe PoccMcKoN $egepa4Ml, 3acny1meHHbA geTelb HaYKM PoccMcKoN $egepaMM (r. MOCKBa, PoccMR)
3aMeCT4Te1I4 rnaBHbIX pegaKTOpOB:
AHApFOWIH C. A., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, npO4 eCCOp, FJaBHbM Hay4HbIN COTpyOHMK, MHCTMTyT 3KOHOMMKM PAH,
KypaTOP HanpaBleH4A 'MOHeTapHaA TeOpH4 1 14H pOBble $I4HaHCbI' (r. MOCKBa, PoccMR)
Ka6aHOB n. A., tOKTOp IopMHAMeCKMX HayK, npO4 eCCOp, tiipeKTOp HMM npOTBOgeNCTBMR KOppy14M Ka3aHCKOFo MHHOBaI4MOHHF0O
YHMBepCMTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpRCOBa (M3Vf), KypaTOP HaflpaBleHA IOpwHt4eCK1wX HayK (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMR)
KpaMH T. B., AOKTOp 3KOHOMM'eCKMX HayK, npO eccop, pipeKTOp HMM npo6neM co4MaJIbHO-3KOHOMMLIeCKOro p3BMTMR pa3BMTR
Ka3aHCKOFO MHHOBI4MOHHOF0 YHMBepCMTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpRCOBa (M3Vf), KypaTOp HanpaBieHiA 3KOHOM4eCK4X HayK (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMR)
OTBeTCTBeHHbA ceKpeTapb:
rpwropbeB P. A., gOKTOp |M)1OCO)MM B 061laCTH 3KOHOMMKM (BenvKo6pvTaHvA), 38MeCTMTelIb pvpeKTOpa HMM npo6neM
coI4manbHO-3KOHOMMH4eCKOro p3BMTM Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBa84MOHHOrO YHMBepCMTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpfCOBa (3Yfl) (r. Ka3aHb, POCCMw)
6apaHOB B. M., AOKTOp iopHAH~eCKMX HayK, npO eccop, 3aCJymeHHbA geRTeIb HaYKM PoccMcKoN $egepaiiM,
nOMOL[4HMK Ha~I~JbHMKa HMHeropoAcKo6 aKageMMM MBA PoccMM no MHHOBa4MOHHOMy pa3BMTIO (r. HM*HMi HOBFOpOA, PoccMR)
BonJb4K B. B., tOKTOp 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, npO4)eccop FO*HOF0 4)egepaIbHOFO YHMBepCMTeTa (r. POCTOB-Ha-AOHy, PoccMR)
rHIwHCKwH A. M., AOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, npO eccop CaHKT-feTep6yprCKOF IO MpHi ~eCKOF0 MHCTMTYTa AKapeMMM reHepanbHOM
npOKypaTypbl PoccMicKoN OegepaMM, PoccMlCKckoro cypapCTBeHHOFO negarorwieCKOrO YHMBepCMTeTa
MM. A. M. epqeHa (r. CaHKT-neTep6ypr, Poccwq)
r0o44eHKo O. r., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, npO eCCop, 4eHTpaIbHbH 3KOHOMMKO-MaTeMaTMLIeCKMN MHCTMTyT
PoccMicKoN aKageMMM HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccMR)
E$I4MLaeBa T. B., tOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, npO4 eccop OpeH6yprCKOFo MHCTMTyTa ((4nHtnana) MOCKOBCKOrFO CyapCTBe HHOrO
IOpHmgmeCKOFO YHMBepCMTeTa MM. O. E. KyTa(4MHa (MFFOA) (r. OpeH6ypr, PoccMR)
KatanoB P. M., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, npO4 eCCop, [eHTpaIbHbH 3KoHoMIKo-MaTeMaTM4eCKN MHCTMTyT
PoccMicKoN aKageMMM HayK (r. MOCKBa, Poccwq)
Ja3apeB B. B., raBHbIM Hay4HbIN COTPYOJHMK 4eHTpa 4 yHgaMeHTaIbHbIX npa1BOBbIX MCCJleAOBaHMH MHCTMTyTa 3aKOHogaTe/bCTBa
M CpaBHMTe/bHOFo npa BBegeHMf npM npaBMTenbCTBe PoccMicKoN Oegepa4MM, gOKTOp IOpHMJMYeCKMX HayK, npO eccop,
3aCnymeHHbM geRTeJIb HaYKM PoccMicKoN $egepaM (r. MOCKBa, PoccMR)
AaTOB K). B., gOKTOp Co4MOJOFmLIeCKMX HayK, KaHAMJaT 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, Begy4HN Hay4HbIM COTPYOJHMK 4eHTpa KOMnIJeKCHbIX
coI4aMJbHbX MCCJleAOBaHMH MHCTMTyTa COI4MOJiOFMM PAH (r. MOCKBa, PoccMR)
JIAneHb C. B., gOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, tOl4eHT MOCKOBCKOFO rocygapCTBeHHOFO KMpHiM~eCKOF0 YHMBepCMTeTa
MM. O. E. Kyra4MHa (MfOA) (r. MOCKBa, PoccMq)
MaKapoBa O. A., AOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, gOl4eHT Ka4 egpbl KOMMep4eCKOFO npaBa CaHKT-feTep6yprCKOrFO CyapCTBe HH0F
YHMBepCMTeTa (r. CaHKT-neTep6ypr, PoccMq)
ManbrH B. A., AOKTOp 3KOHOMM4eCKMX HayK, npO eCCop, 3aCJy1meHHbA geTeJIb HaYKM Pecny6MKM TaTapCTaH (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMR)
Map4eHKO M. H., gOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, npO eccop MOCKOBCKOrFOCygapCTBeHHOFO YHMBepCMTeTa MM. M. B. floMOHocoBa,
3aCnymeJHHbM peTeJIb HaYKM PO (r. MOCKBa, PoccMR)
HypeeB P. M., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, npO4 eCCop, riaBa genapTaMeHTa 3KOHOMMLIeCKOM TeOpMM B OMHaHCOBOM
yHMBepCHTeTe npM paBMTebcTBe PO (r. MOCKBa, Pocc M)
TapaceHKO O. A., AOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, npO eccop MOCKOBCKOFO rocygapCTBeHHOFO KMpHiM~eCKOF0 YHMBepCMTeTa
MM. O. E. Kyra4MHa (MFFOA) (r. MOCKBa, Poccq)
WaNMweBa 3. W., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMLIeCKMX HayK, gOI4eHT Ka egpbl McHegAWeHTa Ka3aHCKOFo MHHOBaI4MOHHOF0 YHMBepCMTeTa
MM. B. F. TMMMpRCOBa (M3 f) (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMR)
Wa@wpoB B. M., gOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, npO eccop CM6MpCKOFo 4egepaJbHOFO YHMBepCMTeTa (r. KpaCHOnpCK, PoccMR)
WeCTaKOB A. A., AOKTOp IOpHMJiYeCKMX HayK, npO4 eccop PoccMNcKoro  cyapCTBeHHOFO negarow4eCKOFO YHMBepCMTeTa
MM. A. M. epqeHa, npe311Me HT CaHKT-feTep6yprCKOFo Me)AyHap0AHf00 KpMMMHO1OFMLeCKOF0 K/ly6a, 3aCJ1yHeHHbA geTeb HaYKM
PoccMicKoN $egepa4M (r. CaHKT-neTep6ypr, PoccMR)
WI4HKeBM4 A. M., AOKTOp 3KOHOMM4eCKMX HayK, AOKTOp TeXHMLIeCKMX HayK, npO4 eccop Ka3aHCKOFo Ha4lMOHa/IbHOF0 MCCJeAOBaTe/IbCKF0O
TeXHO1OFMLIeCKOFO YHMBepCMTeTa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMR)
3APY6EHbIE YJ1EHbI PEAKOAAErm:
AfIM A}m., npO4)eccop 3KOHOMMKM TyneNHCKOFo YHMBepCMTeTa (r. HOBbIl OpneaH, CWA)
AnOCTana KC A., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMKM, npO eccop TeXHOnOM4eCKOFo 06pa3OBaTe/lbHOF0 MHCTMTyTa KpMTa (r. MpaKAiMOH, Fpe4q)
A}ie$pw W., AOKTOp 4MJ1OCO4MM B 06naCTM 3KOHOMMKM, npO eccop YHMBepCMTeTa F. nopTCMyT (r. fopTCMyT, BenMKo6pMTaHMA)
KaMeHKOB B. C., gOKTOp IOpHMJMYeCKMX HayK, npO eCCop, 3aCJy>KeHHbM IOpCT Pecny6MK Benapycb, 3aBegyoJ4MHN Ka4 egpoH
BenopyccKoro rcyapCTBeHHOFO YHMBepCTeTa (r. MMHCK, Pecny6nMKa 6enapycb)
Kypw X., tOKTOp fCMXOJOFMLeCKMX HayK, npo eccop OpaN6yprCKOrO yHMBepCHTera (r. Opai6ypr, FepMaHMA)
MeWKO r., npo4 eCCop, pyKOBOAMTe/b MHCTMTyTa YFOA1OBHOFO npaBOCY11M9 M 6e30naCHOCT  B FCJS YHMBepCMTeTa B MapM6ope;
npe3MJpeHT EBponeNCKON aCCo4MaI4M KpHMMHOJ1OF0B (ESC) (r. MapM6op, CJAOBeHMA)
Py6WH 3. A., npo4 eccop npaBa M IO1MTOJ1OFMM, W Kona npaBa, VHMBepCMTeT BaHJep6MnbTa (r. HeWBM1J1, WT. TeHHeCCM, CWA)
CeppaHo-MaAno A., npo eccop, 3aBegyo4MHA Ka eJpoM yFOJOBHOF0 npaBa M KpMMMHO1OfMM Haq1MoHanbHor0 YHMBepCMTeTa
AMCTaHl4MOHHOFO 06pa30BaHMA (r. Magp ig, McnaHMA)
Type{KRw  H. H., AOKTOp IOpHMJMYeCKMX HayK, npOpeKTOp n0 Hay4HON pa60Te AKapeMMM npaBOOXpaHMTe/IbHbX OpraHOB FeHepanbHON
npOKypaTypbl Pecny6nMK Ka3aXCTaH, npegcegaTeib CoIo3a KpMMMHOJ1OF0B Ka3aXCTaHa MM. E. KaMpmaHOBa
(r. ACTaHa, Pecny6nMKa Ka3aXCTaH)
0wap4yK A., npO eccop YHMBepCMTeTa 3enne1MH (r. 0pHgpMXCXa4 eH, FepMaHMR)

>KypHan 3aperMCTPpOBaH OegepanbHOHn
cnym6oI no HaA30py B crepe CB513M,
MH OpMaLAOHHbIXTeXH0oJOrmN H MaCCOBbIX
KOMMyHKaLAkN.
PerHcTpaLAMOHHoe CBHMeTenbCTBo:
nM No $C77-67150 OT 16 CeHTa6pa 2016 r.
TeppHTopH. pacnpoCTpaHeHMH3:
PoccH~cKaA $egepa1H53; 3apy6e>H ble CTpaH bl.

$OpMaT 60x84/8. YcA. ne4. A. 24,0. Thpam 1000 3K3.
foRnHcaHO B felaTb 25.02.2021. 3aKa3 No 22
AaTa BbiXoga B CBeT 29.03.2021
L4eHa CBo6oAHa
@ HOY BO u(KMY MM. B. [. TMMMp3C0Ba (LAYn)»,
000 T[40 uTarJMMaT», 2020
OTne~aTaHO C rOTOBOrO OpH rkHal-MaKeTa
B TMnorpa M 000 u(BecT aJ1MKaM:
420111, r. Ka3aHb, yn. MocKOBCKa., 22.

Y~peqwTenb H H3qaTeilb -
HOY BO (Ka3aHCKMN
MHHOB3LIMOHH bIN
YHMBepCMTeT MMeHM
B. F. TMMMpnCOBa (L/13Yfl)n
Aqpec peqaKI4HH:
420111,
Pecny6 MKa TaTapCTaH,
r. Ka3aHb,
yf. MOCKOBCKan, 42
Ten.: (843) 231-92-90,
OaKC: 292-61-59
E-mail: apel@ieml.ru
CaNT: apel.ieml.ru
)4ypHar BKAFMoeH
B flepeeHb BAK no rpynne
cneLiManbHOCTeN 08.00.00 -
3KOHOMMVeCKMe HaYKM
/HpeKCMpyeTcn B EBSCO,
ERICH PLUS, HeinOnline,
CyberLeninka, RePEc,
DOAJ, ProQuest
floqnwCKa Ha )KYPHa
no 06bepMHeHHOMy
Karanory (lpecca PoCCMMn
Hawit HHAeKC - 86303
OTBeTCTBeHHbA 3a BbinyCK:
F. 5. LAap' MHoBa
PeqaKTOp:
F. A. TapacoBa
KOMnbloTepHan BepCTKa:
C. A. KapMMoBa
J1H3aHH o6nOWKwM:
E. H. MopooBa
flepeBOA4wK:
KaHA. neA. HayK,
wneH FMnbpAMM
nepeBOAMKOB PT
E. H. BenneBa

11

Pe LeH3HpOBaHHe CTTH B mypHa/e -
ABOH~oe Cnenoe.
fpM LHTHpOBaHHH MaTepmaHnOB CCbIJ1Ka
Ha )yp+Ha1 06fl3aTenbHa.
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a H3J1O>eHHble B CTaTbX 4 aKTbl
HeCYT aBTOpbl. BbIcKa3aHHble B CTaTbAX MHeHM
MOryT He COBnagaTb C TOHKON 3peHM pegaKAMM
H He Hanara oT Ha Hee HHKaKHX 06f3aTebCTB.
MaTep ianbl wypHana ,OCTylHbl
no JIH4eH3HM Creative Commons Attribution License
(http://creativecom mons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing nearly 3,000 academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.



Short-term subscription options include 24 hours, 48 hours, or 1 week to HeinOnline with pricing starting as low as $29.95

Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most