About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

27 Antitrust 69 (2012-2013)
The More Things Change, the More they Stay the Same: Applying Section 5 to Emerging Marketing Practices

handle is hein.journals/antitruma27 and id is 71 raw text is: The More Things Change,
The More They Stay the Same:
ApplyingSection 5 to Emerging Marketing Practices


in new media and marketing technologies have
,Atransformed electronic commerce over the last
twenty-five years, the Federal Trade Com-
mission has continued to protect American
consumers from fraud with a statutory directive that has
remained unchanged since the earliest computers were
employed in the late 1930s, back when no one envisioned
that computers would be used to sell products and services.
The consumer protection prong of Section 5 of the Federal
Trade Commission Act, declaring unfair or deceptive acts or
practices unlawful, is as deliberately broad and general as the
antitrust prong's prohibition on unfair methods of competi-
tion.' The wording of Section 5 allows the Federal Trade
Commission to nimbly adapt its application in the consumer
protection context as technologies change and innovative
platforms for advertising and marketing emerge, and the
Commission has done precisely that.
The last decade has seen an explosion of advertising prac-
tices involving new technologies, from cell phones to the
Internet. To adapt Section 5 to these ever-evolving practices
the FTC can prescribe trade regulation rules identifying the
specific acts or practices that constitute a violation of Section
5.2 However, given the stringent requirements of FTC rule-
making, the Commission has instead applied Section 5 to
these newer practices through strategic enforcement actions,
typically resulting in consent orders, and agency guidelines.3
Although these methods have the benefit of being flexible
and relatively quick, the downside is that they do not nec-
essarily provide clear rules of the road for these new adver-
tising mediums.
This article examines how the FTC has used enforcement
actions and guidance to apply Section 5 to three newer meth-
ods of marketing-affiliate marketing, social media, and
mobile marketing-and explains the implications for busi-
ness compliance.

Affiliate Marketing
In simple terms, affiliate marketers generate interest in a
merchant's products or services, direct leads to the mer-
chant's website, and receive payment from the merchant for
each consumer inquiry or sale generated by the affiliate's
activities. Today's affiliates earn huge payouts, as much as
50 percent of gross revenues, for generating leads or sales for
merchants. Many merchants contract with affiliate net-
works, which manage hundreds of affiliates that indirectly
work for the merchant by sending commercial email mes-
sages, hosting landing pages with content created by the affil-
iate, placing ads on Websites that incentivize consumers to
buy, writing articles, building links, texting, blogging, and
tweeting. Even today, most merchants that use affiliate net-
works remain completely unaware of the identities of the
hundreds or even thousands of affiliates and subaffiliates
working within the network, and must rely on the network
to monitor affiliate behavior and punish bad affiliates.
Affiliate marketing has a rocky legal past, and the FTC was
somewhat slow to bring Section 5 enforcement actions
against affiliates. One of the first notable offensives against
affiliate marketing was private litigation waged by Oprah
Winfrey and Dr. Mehmet Oz, who in 2009 famously sued
about fifty defendants, including several affiliate marketers,
for using their images to sell dietary supplements made with
such ingredients as acai berry and resveratrol.i Among other
things, the complaint alleged fake news Websites, which were
crafted by some affiliates after Dr. Oz appeared on Oprah,
hyped the anti-aging benefits of resveratrol, a substance found
in red wine.' The alleged fake news articles, dubbed farti-
cles, seemed to provide actual reviews of a reporter's thirty-
day trial of resveratrol pills and the positive effects experi-
enced by the reporter.6 The sites were peppered with ads
promoting a free trial of the product reviewed in the report.
Upon settling with the various defendants, Oprah and Dr. Oz
made it clear that they wanted to send a strong message to
prevent marketers engaging in what they deemed to be false
and deceptive marketing practices from taking advantage of
For the FTC's part, legal guidance to merchants and affil-
iate marketers on when conduct may run afoul of Section 5

FALL  2012  69

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing nearly 3,000 academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.

Short-term subscription options include 24 hours, 48 hours, or 1 week to HeinOnline with pricing starting as low as $29.95

Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most