About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

A79557 1 (1918-05-25)

handle is hein.gao/gaobadaed0001 and id is 1 raw text is: 

DECISIONS OF  THE  COMPTROLLER.              705


Awditor  for the War  Depnrtment  in  settlement No. 50851, dated
May  1, 1916, in disallowing his claim for difference between pay as
major  and as colonel from August 5 to 17, 1917, and difference be-
tween pay as lieutenant colonel and as colonel from August 18, 1917,
to March  6, 1918, as follows:
  As  promotion of commissioned  officers of the Regular Army is
regarded, under Army Regulations, as an appointment to a new office,
the pay of the grade to which promoted accruing only from the date
of the acceptance of such promotion, said officer is not entitled to pay
as colonel prior to March 7, 1918, the date he accepted the appoint-
ment  of that grade.                       a
  The  appellant, a major in the Regular Army,  was  appointed a
lieutenant colonel in the National Army  on August  18, 1917; ac-
cepted same  date; was appointed  and promoted  to colonel in the
National Army  as of date August 5, 1917, and promotion announced
by  Special Order, No. 63, War  Department,  published March  16,
1918, accepted March 7, 1918, as stated on copy of order filed.
  Upon  his submitting claim for pay, the quartermaster, March 22,
1918, in a letter to Col. Stewart, states:
   Your appointment  to the grade of colonel, N. A., was not made
so far as is known in this oflice, to fill an existmg vacancy, \nd the
promotion  is not one to which you were required by law to be pro-
moted  by virtue of seniority.. it is therefore regarded as a new
appointment. and  the pay of the higher grade does not commence
until the date of acceptance. For these reasons voucher submitted
bv you  claiming ditIference inl pay between major and colonel from
August  5 to August 17, and difference in pay between lieut. colonel
and  colonel from August 18, 1917, to March 6, 1918, is returned to
you herewith inclosed.
  On  April 4. 1918, the Qunrtermaster General states:
  Colonel Stewart is advised that promotions Th the National Army
are viewed as appointments in a new office, the first sentence of parn-
graph  1260. Army  Regulations, governing, and pay of the higher
grade commences  from  date of acceptance only. *  *  * 
  Pnragraph  1260, Army Regulations, 1913, provides in part, viz:
  A  person appointed to the Army,  or receiving an appointment
to a new  office therein, is entitled to pay from cate of acceptance
only.   *
  It was said in 80 MS. Comp. Dec., 243, August 19, 1917, that-
  It is well understood that an appointment to a new office, except
ill cases of officer-s of the Army promoted thereto by seniority, car-
ries pay in the now office or advanced grade only from date of ac-
ceptance of conunission.
  In the case of the appointment of an officer of the Regular Army
to a command  in the organization composed of members taken from
the National Guard, it was held (24 Comp. Dec., 312) that such ap-
pointment would  be to a new office and that the  date of acceptance


of the appointee is the date from which officers of the Regular Army
temporarily promoted  as a consequence of said appointment will be
entitled to the pay of the grade to which they arc promoted.
  From  the facts appearing I am  of the opinion that the appellant
is not entitled to the increased pay as claimed, on the ground  as
stated by the Quartermaster General, that promotions in the National
Army   are viewed as appointments  in a new office and that pay of
the higher grade commences  from the date of acceptance of the office.
  The  action of the auditor is affirmed and a certificate of no differ-
ences will issue accordingly.

           TAXES ON  PROPERTY  LEASED  BY GOVERNMENT.
Although tases are not payable by the Federal Government as the owner of
    real property, they are properly payable as part of the rent when specifically
    Included In the terms of a lease.
Comptroller Warwick to John W. Swift, Disbursing Officer, United States
    Foo, AdminIstration, Nay 25, 1918:
  I have your letter of May 23, 1918, relative to whether you are au-
thorized under the appropriation  for salaries and expenses of food
administration (40 Stat., 283) to pay real estate taxes upon certain
premises leased by the Food  Administration in the District of Co-
lumbia.
  You  state that  according to my understanding the Federal Gov-
ernment  is exempted  from payment  of  taxes to State and munici-
palities.
   The lease of the premises is from September  10, 1917, until the
termination of the existing war at an annual rental, and specifically
covenants  that the lessee (the United States) shall pay  any and
all taxes that may be assessed upon said demised real property for
the period during  which it is in possession thereof.
   Without at this time deciding any question as to the validity of a
 lease for an indefinite term or for a period longer than that of the
 fiscal year covered by an appropriation (see Chase v. United States,
 155 U. S., 489), I have to inform you that the taxes are not payable
 by the United  States as owner, but as tenant, the taxes becoming
 part of the consideration or rent of the premises, and as such they
 are properly payable, if otherwise correct.

                INJURED  EMPLOYEES'  COMPENSATION.
 The compensation of an injured employee under the act of May 30, 1908, Is pay-
     able at the same rate and under the same conditions that existed when the
     Injury occurred; hence, If at that time the class of workmen to which the
     employee belonged were required to work on Sundays and holidays, said
     Injured employee Is also entitled to be paid for such Sundays and holidays.
     71721-1S-VOL   24--45


704             X)ECISTONS OF THE  COMPTROLLER.

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing thousands of academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.



Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most