About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

19 Tax Foundation's Tax Review 1 (1958)

handle is hein.tera/tafoutaxt0021 and id is 1 raw text is: TAX     FOUNDATION'S                                  JANUARY 1958, Vol. XIX No. I
J i,
Fundamentals oJ Federal Taxation
By Roswell Magill
Chairman, Tax Foundalion, Inc.
T HE first Federal budget after the Sputnik offers Congress two unpleasant choices: either to
invite renewed inflation by piling up additional national debt; or to increase taxes.
Congress has so far greeted the request for an increase in the statutory debt limit to $280
billion with tolerant resignation. At the moment, it appears that we shall resort once again to

deficit spending as the easiest way to avoid
coming to grips with, and so perhaps solving,
our fundamental fiscal problems.
Congress could avoid both diflicult choices by
cutting less essential spending from the budget. The
latter route, of course, is strewn with political ob-
stacles in an election year. Many members of both

Houses are already unhappy
cutbacks in domestic spend-
ing proposed by the President
for fiscal 1959.
If defense spending for mis-
siles and other strange new
weapons exceeds current es-
timates, as such spending has
a tendency to do, we shall
be looking for more revenue
to finance defense.
In such circumstances,
what is likely to happen in
the Congress is what has gen-
erally happened over the past
25 years. Our Federal tax
system today is the product
of a series of emergency ac-
tions by Congress, first to
meet the depression of the
30s, then to meet the needs of

about the very mild

World War II and the Korean War. There has been
no thorough-going Congressional review and appraisal
of the tax system as a whole in the light of recognized
standards for many years.
The Committee on Ways and Means has just
elected a new chairman. with unusually broad ex-
perience in fiscal aflairs. The committee has a moun-
tain of legislation pending before it: a technical
changes act, an excise tax revision bill, a general reve-

nue revision bill. It is cur-
rently engaged in extensive
hearings on the inequities and
failings of the income tax
law. When the hearings are
over, the committee will have
the material to enable it to
consider and determine
whether our tax system is
helping or hindering the
great struggle in which we
as a nation are now engaged.
If the committee were to un-
dertake such a study, what
course should its investigation
take? What should be the
principal fundamental ques-
tions for consideration?
Three criteria of a well-
designed tax system, honored

Copyright 1958 bY Tax FoundaItion, Inc., 30 Rockefeller Phaza, New YinA .0, A'. Y. Alaterial naY be re-used it proper credit.

This Issue in Brief
Adding putches - iore revisions - it)
the nation's tax structure won't lit-Ip it
raise the kind of revenue that the ttissile.
jet age d111u1141s, says IIswell Magill inl
this Iteriew.
What is really n-e4edd, 114 says, is ia
tIllorough-ging revision o(f the existing
St4m11. The lchaniges should Ie! nu111de in
the interest of fairniess, adtleqluacy and cer-
tainty, faetors now obviously lacking in
the structure.
lr.. 111gill suggests that I 1m11ateri llnow
being galthered Ily the Houise4 Ways and
Meanus Coruiltve COUld he uised ats at
1111sis for such revision.
Mere technielI revision of the tIx strue-
111'e, he4' satys, will not solve the probicil's
pose-d, an4d ie- urges that Congress giv'
cousideration nlow to at complete overl-3.

I

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing thousands of academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.



Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most