11 Health Matrix 487 (2001)
Male and Female Genital Alteration: A Collision Course with the Law

handle is hein.journals/hmax11 and id is 493 raw text is: MALE AND FEMALE GENITAL
ALTERATION: A COLLISION
COURSE WITH THE LAW?
Dena S. Davis
I. INTRODUCTION
IN MARCH OF 1999, the American Academy of Pediat-
rics (AAP) released a policy statement on the circumcision of
newborn males, stating that the practice does not have health
benefits strong enough to warrant recommendation as a routine
procedure.' This withdrawal of medical support for routine cir-
cumcision requires us to face some uncomfortable facts, and
raises intriguing constitutional questions.
It is now illegal in the United States to perform genital al-
teration on female minors, no matter how minimal the surgery
or how safe and sanitary the procedure. Newborn male genital
alteration, however, is an accepted procedure in the U.S. Al-
though there is some controversy over this practice, for most
people it is a familiar part of life in America. The law takes no
cognizance of the male procedure, with no records kept of cir-
cumcisions performed outside of hospitals, and with no over-
sight or licensing of ritual practitioners.
Why does the law turn a blind eye to one procedure and
criminalize the other? Two possible answers present them-
selves. The first answer claims that male genital alteration is
medically beneficial, whereas female genital alteration is purely
cultural. As I will show later in this article, this is a weak ar-
gument. There are no health benefits to the female procedures,
certainly, but the health benefits for males are contested and
tenuous.
t Professor, Cleveland-Marshall College of Law. B.A., Marlboro College;
J.D., University of Virginia; Ph.D. (Religion), University of Iowa.
1 See Task Force on Circumcision, American Academy of Pediatrics, Circum-
cision Policy Statement, 103 PEDIATRIcS 686 (1999) [hereinafter AAP, Circumcision
Policy Statement] (reviewing medical literature concerning circumcision).
487

What Is HeinOnline?

With comprehensive coverage of government documents and more than 2,300 journals from inception on hundreds of subjects such as political science, criminal justice, and human rights, HeinOnline is an affordable option for colleges and universities. Documents have the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database.



Short-term subscription options include 24 hours, 48 hours, or 1 week to HeinOnline with pricing starting as low as $29.95

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?