27 Am. J. Crim. L. 329 (1999-2000)
Should Lost Evidence Mean a Lost Chance to Prosecute: State Rejections of the United States Supreme Court Decision in Arizona v. Youngblood

handle is hein.journals/ajcl27 and id is 339 raw text is: Notes
Should Lost Evidence Mean a Lost Chance
to Prosecute?: State Rejections of the United
States Supreme Court Decision in Arizona v.
Youngblood
Table of Contents
I.   Introduction    ....................................................................................... 331
II.  B ackground     ....................................................................................... 335
A. The Law ofAccess to Evidence Before Arizona v. Youngblood.. 336
B. Arizona v. Youngblood: A Standard is Set ................................... 337
1. The Legal History and Holding of Youngblood ...................... 338
a. Justice Rehnquist's Majority Opinion ................................ 338
b. Justice Stevens' Concurring Opinion ................................ 340
c. Justice Blacknun 's Dissent ................................................ 340
2. Reasons Behind the Majority Ruling ....................................... 341
3. The Effect and Non-effect of Youngblood ............................... 342
4. A Number of State Courts Have Agreed with Youngblood ..... 343
a.  California   ........................................................................... 343
b.  A rizona  ............................................................................... 344
c. Maine and Ohio ................................................................. 346
C. A Different Approach: States Begin to Move Away from
Y oungblood     .................................................................................. 348
1. Disagreement with the Ruling in Youngblood ........................ 348
a.  A laska  ................................................................................. 348
b.  D elaware ............................................................................ 349
c.  Tennessee    ........................................................................... 351
2. Reasons States Began to Disagree. ......................................... 351
a.  A laska  ................................................................................. 352
b.  D elaw  are ............................................................................ 352
c.  Tennessee    ........................................................................... 353
d. Other States and Their Reasoning ..................................... 353
D. Two Viable Theories on Lost Evidence and Due Process ............ 354
1. Bad Faith Required ................................................................. 354
a.  A rizona  ............................................................................... 354
b.  F lorida  ............................................................................... 355
2. Bad Faith Not Required .......................................................... 356
a. The Majority Anti-Youngblood Approach ......................... 356

What Is HeinOnline?

With comprehensive coverage of government documents and more than 2,300 journals from inception on hundreds of subjects such as political science, criminal justice, and human rights, HeinOnline is an affordable option for colleges and universities. Documents have the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database.



Short-term subscription options include 24 hours, 48 hours, or 1 week to HeinOnline with pricing starting as low as $29.95

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?