About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

104-10331-10309 JFK Assassination Records Archives 1 (2/20/1995)

handle is hein.jfk/jfkarch19236 and id is 1 raw text is: S1O4.iO331~1O3O9


CONFIDENTIAL


NOTE  FOR:          John F. Pereira @ DA
FROM:
DATE:               02120195  11:33:42 AM
SUBJECT:            IdAids

          As you may remember  the Board, ie, David Marwell, took issue on several counts with the Id Aids and the disks that we
recently provided. Their concerns, 4 in number, and my recommendations to remedy those concerns are listed below. Some of their
concerns can be relieved, some may not. The larger issue is the amount of resources that may be needed to make the kinds of
adjustments they require. Initially we are talking about the 11 Oswald boxes. The remainder of the file will be harder to adjust 'because
of the large amount of documents|1dAids, because the file is not in its original form (3rd Agency, HSCA) and because the audit is not
completed (IdAids matched to documents in file). There is also the lurking possibility that to provide the missing data we may be forced to
access the file data manually.


                    Concern 1: Classification Status
                              The original classification status of the do
IdAid. This issue is not a new one, it has been discussed before with
the Id Aid reflects the tatus of the IdAid
all are
                              Unclassified. The data is in our file, howe
                              field at input there may be instances who


          Recommendation:   Have'jiiuery for
          if there are a lot of blanks and, if the num
          change. If the numbers are not right, ie, l
          field, we need to regroup.

Concern 2: Non Matching Hard  Copy IdAid and Digit
          Mr. Marwell produced 2 versions of the s
          hard copy IdAid collection we provided an
          provided. I have talked to~iidelpbout thi
          program and firmly believes it to be impos
          same record.  I will talk to im n Tuesda
          error. I will also call NARA and ask them
          comparison. My  searches have produced


cument  was not provided on the
                               NARA.    i'data recorded on
 andlor the version of the-document currently at NARA,- namely

 ver, since it was not a required
re the field is blank.                   ±Y

blanks in the field to determine
bers are right, make the program
arge number of blanks in this


al Id Aid
ame index record - 1 from the
d one from the disks we
s and she has checked the
sible to have 2 versions of the
y but I view this as a human
to. pull this record for
no duplicates.


                              Recommendation:   Talk to Mr. Marwell again to find out exactly how he
                              found the duplicate record and if more were discovered. Depending on
                              his reply I would suggest that this be categorized as a human error.

                    Concern 3: Referred  Documents  having a classification status
                              In his manipulation of the disk data Mr. Marwell discovered numerous
                              instances where a document was  marked for referrallcoordination and
                              also carried a classification status, eg, RIF, , DIF. He reasons that if
                              a document is referred it should carry a P for Pending in the
                              c        tion status field. oan  forms me that the program inserts a
                              Re          arking when the document originator is anything but CIA. This
marking was  not inserted by the i exers but by the program. The theory
                               being that if the document was not CIA it waslis coordinated. It was also
                               reasoned that iflwhen the document had completed its coordination run it
                               was provided to NARA with an appropriate IdAid. The original August
                               release included IdAids for those documents pending coordination - the
                               IdAids appropriately stamped with Pending Coordination - but no
                               documents were attached. The difficulty here is a difference in


CONFIDENTIAL

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing thousands of academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.



Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most