About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

B-178594 1 (1973-11-20)

handle is hein.gao/gaobaaduk0001 and id is 1 raw text is: 



















      9  94


' ' .,. . . ' .. it *
    9


.9

9 (


7    .9



     9 ~




~'1785M


*0 9 ~

     99


9 , ' V l O


' ,t':I'


)OMPTVOLLEI -GEM&tAL. OF 'Ti UNITED STATES
           a


w 0


1
-'S


9      9


I -


0 $99


-   9


   9 '

- • 9 999


| -

9


Chubrln-aruhrt Coo, Ina

140 llighdand Ctreet

Port Chester, Htiw Yora. 10573


9


Noveubnk 20, 1973


  e991.

I1 -  I'..... 

     9   *


9.0


      Attention;  Mr., dwiu A. Zarnhart
- . ,l resdmnt


C0Ortloman:


9   9


,4-
,.p


- 4.- 9 -. 9'
   9~
     99 $ 9YW ~'4.
     * ** ci.. -be


*  4 .4
V -     -
  4
* **,*   * ':


9.

* .9      S
                 9'f*,

 9

 * S *      S
     9*.9 *  ..- 9*4~~
     9     9.
     99    9     9
  9
*     .s9
9   4 * 9    9.9~9


A  *


1 * 1 !


9. 9    99


     Thin In in reply to your letter of Ajust 24, 1973,.to a Hoabet

 of he oSenate, which was forwarded to our Office, requeoting reon-

.sideration of our decinlon, 1-178594, of August 39 1973, which denied

your protest against the alloged restrictivo character of the specifi-W

catio'no in invitation for bids (l) No, 65-73, issued by Sant

SlizAbetho )opital, Department of Ualth, £ducation, and-Valfare






     Tha banis of your protest continues to be that the speciications

used In the ZFB required the furniohing of a detention screen eonrtructcd

with a bo.-typae franc, vwhilo your vcereen enploys the open channil noethod

of construction, Only one company wanufactureo a screen with the box

frame, Ifetal. Construction Services Corporation (HCSC), the only fim to

uubmit a bid under the nolkcitation nnd the subsequent awardee. There-

fore, you belivo the ospecification was redtrictive of copetition.


      In cur decision of August 3, we pointed out that the doterAntion
 of the actual needs of the Government rests primarily with the procuritg;



 agency and the record before our Office revbaled that in a prior procuvA-

 tent by the hospital, you had furnished the box-typo fr=a. For those

 reasons, ve concluded the spociflcatios %taro not restrictive.



      n y     letter of August 24, 3973, requesting reconnideration,

 you utt at you loot money on the prior contract requiring tho box-

 type fr=a a. that when the recent IYB was slsued, you attemptod to

 have the apeoificaions changed but to no avail. Furthermora, you

 have told the hospital that your oc.eens eet the requircments but they

..conti u to use the box-typa apecificatiomos.


V

  9....  '      Our Office has abald that the Govnrnment may not be placed in the







  . *  . . - • ,A ai•, , S               - - •• , . , = - -
  ______________mof.*asuwiwj bidiltrstw eictateuspeiuttcattoa  wch  ifl pcrw&  -




         9                              40


.    ,9 9 9, . ° , ' .  . .         , , . . , - . : . . . l - ~ C - 9 4 U . . 9 . .* . . ~ 9. *

:-:    :'- ' - ..... ,* *. '.-__9 .:.    .        -  l   '), f'    . ..



       .l._.                  ..JI                               /..., .. J ,. _ . ,.. . ., . __- .. .' . •
                           *  A 9,                                      ae, a
                  to*                                             9    9
                                  Ira


'.,4  jt


p*, s  ni


6p9


9
it.


..~ II


4


€


o


0


. I v 9


4.


• @ •


i •

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing thousands of academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.



Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most