About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

2024 Russ. J. Econ. & L. 1 (2024)

handle is hein.journals/apel2024 and id is 1 raw text is: 








                                                                                                                                       Tom 18, N21


RUSSIANJOURNAOF ECONOMICSAND LAW                                                                                                              2024
                                                                                                                                   DOI: 10.21202/2782-2923.2024.1


                                                  DOI:  10.21202/2782-2923
                          M3AaeTCs   c sHBaps  2007  roga, nepHOH4HOCTb M34aHHR - 4 pa3a B roA

PEAAKL4HOHHAR   KOAAErH
rnaBHblI pepaKTop:
KneMHep r. B., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMHeCKMX HayK, npO4)eCcop, HJleH-KOppecnOHgeHT PoccMNcKOA aKageMMM HayK, 3aMeCTMTefib HayHHOFO pyKOBOAHTe/A
   L4eHTpailbHOro 3KOHOMMKO-MaTeMaTMHeCKOFo MHCTHTyra PoccMNcKOA aKageMMM HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccMB)
Co rnaBHbIH pepaKTop:
BMKeeB H. M., AOKTOp IOpMMHeCKMX HayK, npO4 eCCOp, 3aCny>KeHHblA IOpMCT Pecny6MKM TaTapCTaH, nepBblA npopeKTOp, npope0KTOp no HayHHOA pa6OTe
   Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBa4MOHHOFO YHHBePCHTeTa HMeHM B. F. TMMMpsCOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccM6)
3ameaTmTem rnaBHoro pepaKTopa:
AHApOWHH  C. A., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMHeCKMX HayK, npO4 ecCop, FJaBHbIA HayHHbIA COTpyDHMK MHCTMTyra 3KOHOMMKM PoccMNcKOA aKageMMM HayK (r. MOCKBa,
   POccHA)
Ka6aHOB fl. A., gOKTOp IOpMMHeCKMX HayK, npO4 eCCOp Ka4,egpbl KpMMMHOAOFMM, HHKeropOCKan aKageMMA MBA PoccMM (r. HH>HMA HOBropog, PoccMB),
   KypaTOp HanpaBleHMH IOpHAMeCKMX HayK
KpaMHH T. B., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMHeCKMX HayK, npO,ecCOp, gMpeKTOp HMM npo6neM co4ma/lbHo-3KoHOMMHeCKOFo pa3BMTM Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBa4MOHHOFO
   yHHBepCHTeTa HMeHM B. F. TMMMpsCOBa, KypaTop HanpaBneHMH 3KOHOMM~eCKHX HayK (r. Ka3aHb, PoccM6)
OTBeTCTBeHHblI ceKpeTapb:
rpwropbeB P. A., gOKTOP H MAOCO4MM B o6laCTH 3KOHOMMKM (BeMKO6pMTaHMA), 3aMeCTMTefib  KTopa HMM npo6neM co4ma/lbHo-3KoHOMMHeCKOFo pa3BHTHA
   Ka3aHCKOrO MHHOBaLHOHHOFO YHHBePCHTeTa HMeHM B. F. THMMpscOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMB)
AHTOHOBa M. M., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMHeCKMX HayK, AOLeHT, npOpe KTOp no MHHOBa4MOHHO-npoeKTHOM genTeibHOCTM Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBa4MOHHOFO yHHBePCHTeTa
   HMeHM B. F. TMMMpsCOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMB)
BapaHOB B. M., gOKTOp IOpMMeCKMX HayK, npO4 ecCOp, 3aCAy>KeHHbIA genTeJib HayKM PoccMHcKOA Oegepa4mm, fOMOLI4HMK Ha~aJlbHMKa HH>eropOCKOA
   aKageMMM MBA PoccMM no HHHOBaLHOHHOMy pa3BMTMHO (r. HH>HHH HOBropog, PoccMB)
BerwueB H. P., gOKTOp IOpMMHeCKMX HayK,  opeHT, 3aC/ly>KeHHb IOpMCT Pecny6nHKH TaTapCTaH, npo4,eccop Ka4,egpbl yFOJ1OBHOFO npaBa H npowecca
   Ka3aHCKOro HHHOBa4HOHHOFO yHHBePCHTeTa HMeHM B. F. THMMpsCOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccM)
BOnbHMK B. B., AOKTOp 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npO ecCop lO>KHOFO  egepalbHOFOyHHBepCHTeTa (r. PocTOB-Ha-AOHy, POCCMH)
rHHHCKMH A. M., gOKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 ecCop CaHKT-fleTep6yprCKOro FOpHeHHCKOFO HHCTHTyTa AKageMHH FeHepa/lbHOA npOKypaTypbl
   PoccMHcKOA Oegepa4HH, PoccMHcKOrO roCy apCBe HHOrO negarorHHeCKOro yHHBepCHTeTa HMeHM A. M. FeppeHa (r. CaHKT-nleTep6ypr, PoccMH)
ronH~eHKo O. r., AOKTOP 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npO4)ecCop [4eHTpalbHOFO 3KOHOMHKO-MaTeMaTHHeCKOFo HHCTHTyTa PoccMHcKOA aKageMHH HayK
   (r. MOCKBa, PoccM)
ronOBYMH M. A., KaH,HgaT 9KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, CTapwH M HayHHbIA COTpyDHHK BonoroacKorO HayHHOFO  eHTpa PoccMHcKOA aKageMHH HayK
   (r. Bonorpga, PoccM)
E$HMmLeBa T. B., gOKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npo4 eccop OpeH6yprCKOro HHCTHTyTa (4HAHanla) MocKOBCKOro FOCyOapCTBeHHHOrO IopHHeCKOFO yHHBePCHTeTa
   HMeHM 0. E. KYTa4HHa (r. OpeH6ypr, PoccMH)
Ka~anOB P. M., AOKTOP 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 ecCop |4eHTpalbHOFO 3KOHOMHKO-MaTeMaTHHeCKOFo HHCTHTyTa PoccMHcKOA aKageMHH HayK
   (r. MOCKBa, PoccM)
KopbITreB M. A., AOKTOP 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 ecCop |O>KHOFO  egepaJlbHoro yHHBePCHTeTa (r. PocTOB-Ha-AOHy, PoccMH)
KygpHBLeBa O. B., gOKTOp 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npo4 eccop MocKOBCKOro rOCygapCTBeHHOrO yHHBepCHTeTa HMeHM M. B. IlOMOHOCOBa (r. MOCKBa, PoccMH)
Jla3apeB B. B., gOKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 eCcop, FAaBHbIA HayHHbIA COTpyDHHK [4eHTpa 4,yHgaMeHTalbHbIX npaBOBbIX HCCJlegOBaHMA MHCTHTyTa
   3aKOHogaTefbCBa H CpaBHHTefibHOFO npaBOBegeHM npH npaBHTefibCTBe PoccMHcKOA Oegepa4HH, 3aCny>KeHHbIl genTeib HayKH PoccMHcKOA Oegepa4HMH
   (r. MOCKBa, PoccM)
JiaToB 10. B., AOKTOP CO4HOAOFHHeCKHX HayK, KaH,HgaT 9KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, BegyLI4HA HayHHbIA COTpyDHHK |4eHTpa KOMnfleKCHbIX CO4HaJlbHbIX
   Mccn egOBaHHMA MHCTHTyTa CO4HOAOFHM PoccMHcKOA aKageMHH HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccMH)
JleBMH C. H., AOKTOP 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 eCcop OHHaHCOBOFO yHHBePCHTeTa npH npaBHTefibCBe PoccMHcKOA Oegepa4HM (r. MOCKBa, POCCMH)
IlwneHb C. B., gOKTOP IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, gopeHT MocKOBCKOro FOCyOapCTBeHHHOrO IopHHeCKOFO yHHBePCHTeTa HMeHM 0. E. KYTa4HHa (r. MOCKBa, PoccMH)
MaKapoBa O. A., gOKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, gopeHT Ka4,egpbl KOMMepeHCKOFO npaBa CaHKT-neTep6yprCKOro roCygapCTBeHHOro yHHBePCHTeTa
   (r. CaHKT-neTep6ypr, PoccMH)
MaA1KHHa M. 10., AOKTOp 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npo4 eccop HH>eropOCKOro FOyaPCTBeHHOrO yHHBepCHTeTa MM. H. M. Jlo6a~eBCKOro
   (r. HHKHMA HoBropog, PoCCHs)
neTpHHMH A. B., AOKTOP IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 eCcop, AHpeKTOp HH>eropOCKOro 4HHala CaHKT-fleTep6yprCKOA aKageMHH CnleACTBeHHoO KOMHTeTa Pct
   (r. HHKHMA HoBropog, PoCCMH)
flOAonbHbIl H. A., AOKTOP IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, AopeHT, 3aBegylOL.4HM Ka4,egpoA yFOJOBHOFO npopeCCa H KpHMHHa/lHCTHKH Ka3aHCKOrO HHCTHTyTa (4H/lHa/la)
   BcepoccM cKOrO roCygapCBeHHOrO yHHBepCHTeTa IOCToHLHM (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMH)
TapaceHKo H. A., AOKTOP IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npo4 eccop MocKOBCKOro   FOCyHaPCTBe HHOrO IopHHHeCKOFO yHHBePCHTeTa HMeHM 0. E. KYTa4HHa
   (r. MOCKBa, PoccM)
XwcaMoBa 3. M., KaH,HmaT IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, Ha~aJlbHHK OTAeJleHMA nlJaHHpOBaHMA H KOOpAHHa4HM HayHHOA AenTeibHOCTH HayNHO-HCCJlegoBaTeJibCKoro
   OTAena KpacHogapCKOro yHHBepCHTeTa MHHHCTepCTBa BHyTpeHHHX Aen PoccMHcKOA Oeepa4HM (r. KpacHogap, PoccMH)
Wa@wpoB  B. M., AOKTOP IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 eCcop CH6HpCKOro  egepaJlbHoro yHHBepCHTeTa (r. KpacHOBpCK, PoccMH)
WecraKOB A. A., AOKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npo4,eccop PoccMHcKOrO roCy a pCBeHHOrO negarorHHeCKOro yHHBepCHTeTa HMeHM A. M. FeppeHa, npe3HAeHT
   CaHKT-fleTep6yprCKOro Me>KAyHapOgHOrO KpHMHHOJ1OFHHeCKOFO K/ly6a, 3aC/ly>KeHHbIA AenTeib HayKH POCCMHCKOA Oeepa4HM (r. CaHKT-nleTep6ypr, PoccMH)
WHHKeBMY A. H., AOKTOP 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, AOKTOP TeXHHHeCKHX HayK, npo4 eccop Ka3aHCKOro Ha4HOHa/lbHOFO HCCJleAOBaTeJibCKOro TeXHOAlOrHHeCKOro
   YHHBePCHTeTa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMH)
ijenenbKOB B. m., AOKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 eCcop, npO4,ecCop Ka4,egpbl yFOJ1OBHOFO npaBa CaHKT-fleTep6yprCKOro r FOyaPCTBeHHOrO yHHBepCHTeTa
   (r. CaHKT-nleTep6ypr, PoccMH)
3APYBE}KHblE YJ1EHbl PEAKOIIIErHH:
AllM AK., AOKTOp 4HJ1OCO4)HH B o6laCTH 3KOHOMHKH, npO4,eCCOp 3KOHOMHKH TyneAHCKOro yHHBePCHTeTa (r. HOBblA OpneaH, CWA)
AnocraanaKc A., AOKTOP 4HJ1OCO4,HH B 06/laCTH 3KOHOMHKH, npO4,eCcop Fpe~eCKOro CpeAH3eMHOMOpCKOrO yHHBePCHTeTa (r. MpaK/lHOH, FpeL4HA)
Wa66ap A>., AOKTOP 4HJ1OCO4,HH B o6laCTH 3KOHOMHKH, npO4,eCcop YHHBepCHTeTa F. flOpTCMyT (r. flopTCMyT, Be/lHKO6pHTaHMA)
KaMeHKOB B. C., AOKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 ecCop, 3aC/ly>KeHHbIA IOpHCT Pecny6/lHKH Beilapycb, HayHHbIA KOHCy/lbTaHT Ka4,egpbI BeilOpyCCKOro
   rocy apcTBeHHOrO YHHBePCHTeTa (r. MHHCK, Pecny6/lHKa Be/lapycb)
Kypw X., AOKTOP 4HJ1OCO4)HH B o6laCTH nCMXOJOrFHH, npO,ecCop OpaA6yprCKOro YHHBePCHTeTa (r. OpaA6ypr, FepMaHMA)
MewKO  r., AOKTOP )HJOCO)HH B o6/laCTH npaBa, npo4,eccop, pyKOBOAHTefib MHCTHTyTa yFOJ1OBHOFO npaBOCygHa H 6e3onaCHOCH B YHHBepcHTeTe MapH6opa;
   npe3mAeHT EBpone ACKoO KpHMHHOJ1OFHHeCKOFO 061eCTBa (ESC) (r. MapH6op, CJlOBeHMA)
Py6HH 3. II., npo4,eccop npaBa H noJ1HTOJloFHM WKOJlbI npaBa YHHBepCHTeTa BaHAep6H/lbTa (r. HewBM/1/1, CWA)
CeppaHo-MaMuno A., npo4,eccop, 3aBegylOLI4HA Ka4,egpoA yFOJOBHOFO npaBa H KpHMHHOJ1OFHM HagHoHaJlbHOro yHHBepCHTeTa AHCTaH4HOHHOFO 06pa3OBaHM
   (r. MagpHA, McnaHM)
Type4KMA H. H., ROKTOp IOpHRHHeCKHX HayK, HJleH HayHHO-KOHCy/lbTaTHBHOFO COBeTa npH KOHCTHTyLHOHHOM Cype Pecny6/lHKH KaXa3cTaH
   (r. AcraHa, Pecny6/lHKa Ka3aXcTaH)
0mHApyK A., AOKTOP 3KOHOMHHeCKHX HayK, npO4 eCcop YHHBepCHTeTa 3enne/lHH (r. OcpHpHXCXa4,eH, FepMaHMA)


Y4pepMTenb:
HOY  BO  «(Ka3aHCKHL4
H HHOBaLWOHH0lI
yHHBepCHTeT HMeHM
B. F.THMHp5COBa»

Ma3aTenb:
000   «TLt0  «Tar l71aT»

Appec   pepaK4MM:
420111,
Pecny6AHKa   TaTapCTaH,
r. Ka3aHb,
yl. MOCKOBCKaI,   42

Ten.: (843) 231-92-90,
IaKC:  292-61-59
E-mail: rusjel@ieml.ru
Ca HT: rusjel.ru

WKypHal  BK/ll-IeH
B  ~lepeIeHb  BAK
no  CneL4,aJlbHOCThM:
5.2.1. 3KOHOMMLeCKaI
TeopHW;
5.2.3. PerLEOHallbH2an
H OTpaCJle Ba  3KOHOMLIKa;
5.1.4. YrOnOBHO-npaBoBble
H ayKH

IHreKCHpyeTCfl B   HelnOnlne,
CyberLeninka,   RePEc,  DOAJ,
ProQuest














folnMCKa Ha WKypHal
no  06beAHHeHHOMy
KaTaJ1Ory « flpecca PoccH H»
HaL   MHeKC   - 86303

OTBeTCTBeHHbIM 32 BbinyCK:
F S. . apHHHOBa

PepaKTOp:
F. A. TapacoBa

KomnbloTepHas BepCTKa:
C. A. KapHMOBa

AM4aMH   06/aO»KKM:
. H. 3arpeTrHHOBa

AM32MH   IorOTMna:
B. A. KpaHKOB

fiepeBOA4MK:
KaHA.  ne.  HayK,
-IleH FHvbHwH
nepe BOHA   KOB  PT
E. H. BenIleBa

AypMOKOHTeHT caMTa:
000   «(OJlOC HayKH»


I                                                                             -


>KypHaA 3apeHCTpI-pOBaH  $ejepanbHOw  cnym6oi
no HaA30py B Crepe CBR3H-I, HH4opMaH4IoHHblX
TeXHO/IOf H MaCCOBbIX  KOMMyHHKa4iHi.

PerHCTpaqHoHHbIl  HOMep H AaTa npHHRTIH
peliueHMR O perHCTpa4H:
f1/H Ns OC77-81556 OT 27 MIonA 2021 r.

TeppHTOpwH  pacnpoCTpaHeHMAIR:
POCCHNCKan $egepaqI-;  3apy6e*Hble CTpaHbl.


OopMaT  60x84/8. YcA. ne4. A. 35,25. Twpam 1000 3K3. lOAn MCaHO B ne4Tb 27.02.2024. 3aKa3 Ne 18.

AaTa BblXOJa B CBeT 27.03.2024. 4eHa CBo6oAHaR.

©  40V BO «KVV  Mm. B. -. TwMwpnCOBa», 000 «T40 «TafJIMmaT), 2024.

OTne4aTaHO  C FOTOBOFO OpMMHa/-MaKeTa  B THnorpaMH  000  «BeCT  a/IHKa»: 420111, F. Ka3aHb, yn. MOCKOBCKaR, 22.

Pe4eH3HpoBaHwe  CTaTe  B MypHa/le - ABOAHoe cienoe. npH 4HTHpoBaHHH MaTepHIOaAB CCbIAKa Ha *ypHa/I o63aTe/IbHa.

           MaTepHanbl ypHa/la   AOCTynHbl no II4eH3HM Creative Commons  Attribution License
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing thousands of academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.



Short-term subscription options include 24 hours, 48 hours, or 1 week to HeinOnline.

Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most