![handle is hein.journals/apel2023 and id is 1 raw text is:
RUSSI aN JOURNL OF ECONOMICS AN[ LAW
Tom17, N1
2023
D001: 10.21202/2782-2923.2023.1
DOI: 10.21202/2782-2923
M3AaeTCs C FIHBapi 2007 rOga, nepHOAM4HOCTb H34aHHR - 4 pa3a B rnA
PEAAKL4MOHHAA KOiI1IEFMi
FnaBHbi pepaKTOp:
KneHep F. E., AOKTOP 3K0HOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop, 4lieH-KoppecnOHAeHT POCCMkCKOM aKageMMM HayK, 3aMeCTMTeJ1b HayHHOF0
PyKOBOAMTelIJI LeHTpallbHOFO 3KoHoMMKO-MaTeMaTMNeCKOFo MHCTMTYTa POCCMkCKOM aKageMMM HayK (F. MOCKBa, PoccNi)
Co rnaBHbai pepaKTOp:
ELKeeB 1. 1., AOKTOOp 0 opANgeCKMX HayK, npO4)eccop, 3aCjy>KeHHblM IOpMCT Pecny 6lMKM TaTapCTaH, fepBblM npopeKTOp, n0popeKTOP
nO HayHHO pa6oTe Ka3aHCKOro MHH0Ba4M0HHOFo yHNBePCNTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpICOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccHw)
3aMeCTTen1I rnaBHoro pepaKTOpa:
AHApIowHH C. A., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop, FJlaBHblM HayHHblM COTPYAHMK HHCTMTyTa 3KOHOMMKM POCCMkCKOM aKageMMM
HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccwN)
Ka6aHoB ni. A., AOKTOP IOpHANLeCKMX HayK, npOcjeCCOp Kac egpbl KpMMMHOJ1OFM, HMeropOACKan aKageMNTI MBA PoccMM
(r. HM>KHwM HOBropOA, PoccwI), KypaTOp HanpaneHH IopHAteCKX HayK
KpaMMH T. B., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop, AgpeKTOp HVT npo61leM co4lanbHo-3KoHOMMNeCKOFo pa3BMTMfI
Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBaI4MOHHOFO yHNBepCwTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpICOBa, KypaTOp HanpaneHH 3KoHOMLNeCKX HayK (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
OTBeTCTBeHHbIl ce KpeTapb:
FpwropbeB P. A., AOKTOP @MnIOCO@MM B 06laCTM 3KOHOMMKM (BejiMKO6pMTaHMB), 3aMeCTMTeJ1b AgpeKTOpa HVT npo6/leM
co4lmanbHO-3KOHOMNleCKOM pa3BMTMNI Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBaI4MOHHOFO yHNBepCwTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpICOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
AHTOHOBa 1. 1., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, Ao4eHT, nOpe KTOP nO MHHOBaI4MOHHO-npoeKTHOM AefITejlbHOCTM Ka3aHCKOro
MHHOBaI4MOHHOFO yHNBepCTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpICOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccHw)
EapaHoB B. M., AOKTOp IOpHAgMNCKMX HayK, npO(jeccop, 3aCj1y>KeHHblM gelTeilb HayKM POCCMkCKOM Oegepa4MM, nOMOLLAHMK Ha~aHIbHMKa
HMKeropOACKOM aKageMNN MBA PoccMM nO MHHOBaI4MOHHOMy pa3BMTMIO (r. HM>HMM HOBropOA, Pocc~N)
Eer~weB 1. P., AOKTOP IOpAMNgeCKMX HayK, 3aCj1y>KeHHblM IOpMCT Pecny6/nMKM TaTapCTaH, CTapWM HayHHblM COTPYAHMK Ka3aHCKOro
MHHOBaI4MOHHOFO yHNBepCTeTa MM. B. F. TMMMpICOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
BOnibHK B. B., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop O>K)HOFO egepallbHOro yHNBePCNTeTa (r. POCTOB-Ha-AOHy, PoccwI)
FL/IHCKLi K. 1., AOKTOp IOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, npO(jeccop CaHKT-leTep6yprCKOro IOpHAgMNCKOFO MHCTMTYTa AKageMMM [eHepallbHO
npOKypaTypbl POCCMCKOM Oegepa4MM, POCCMkCKOro rocygapCTBeHHOro negarorNeCKOro yHNBepCwTeTa MM. A. V. FepLjeHa
(r. CaHKT-fleTep6ypr, Poccwn)
FonwteHKO O. F., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop L eHTpallbHOFO 3KoHoMMKO-MaTeMaTMNeCKOFo MHCTMTyTa POCCMCKOM aKageMMM
HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccMNs)
E0LML1eBa T. B., AOKTOP IOpHAgMNCKMX HayK, npOjeccop OpeH6yprCKOro MHCTMTYTa (#MnIMalla) MOCKOBCKOro rocygaPCTBeHHOro
IOpNAMNeCKOFO yHNBePCNTeTa MM. O. E. Kyra@MHa (MFFOA) (r. OpeH6ypr, PoccNi)
Ka~anOB P. M., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop L eHTpallbHOFO 3KoHoMMKo-MaTeMaTMNeCKOFo MHCTMTyTa POCCMCKOM aKageMMM
HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccMNs)
KopbITn4eB M. A., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop FO>KHOFO egepallbHOro yHNBePCNTeTa (r. POCTOB-Ha-AOHy, PoccMF)
KyppnBAteBa O. B., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop MOCKOBCKOro ocy ap CTBeHHOMo yHMBePCNTeTa MM. M. B. JlOMOHOCOBa
(r. MOCKBa, PoccMN)
Jla3apeB B. B., rlaBHblM Hay HblM COTPYAHMK L eHTpa (yHAaMeHTalbHblX nlpaBOBbIX MCCJleAOBa HM /HCTMTyTa 3aKOHOgaTeIbCTBa
M CpaBHMTeJ1bHOFO npaBOBegeHMfi npm lpaBMTenlbCTBe POCCMCKO Oegepa4MM, AOKTOP IOpAMNgeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop,
3aCJly>KeHHbIM gelTeilb HayKM POCCMCKOM Oegepamm (r. MOCKBa, PoccNi)
laTOB K0. B., AOKTOP COI4MO/IOFMNHCKMX HayK, KaHAMgaT 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, BegyL4M Hay HblM COTPYAHMK L eHTpa KOMfleKCHbIX
COI4MalJbHblX MCCJleAOBaHM /HCTMTyra COI4MOJiOFM POCCMCKOM aKageMMM HayK (r. MOCKBa, Poccmi)
JIneHb C. B., AOKTOP IOpHAgMNCKMX HayK, AOI4eHT MOCKOBCKOro rocyap CTBeHHOro IOpHAgMNCKOFO yHNBePCNTeTa MM. O. E. KyTa(MHa
(MflOA) (r. MOCKBa, Poccwn)
MaKapoBa O. A., AOKTOP IOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, AOI4eHT Kac egpbl KOMMepeHCKOFO npaBa CaHKT-leTep6yprCKOro rocygaPCTBeHHOro
yHMBepCMTera (r. CaHKT-fleTep6ypr, Poccwn)
HypeeB P. M., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop, r/laBa genapTaMeHTa 3KOHOMMNHCKOM TOpwM B OMHaHCOBOM yHNBePCNTeTe
npw flpaBMTenbcTBe PO (r. MOCKBa, Poccwn)
TapaceHKO O. A., AOKTOP IOpHAgMNCKMX HayK, npOjeccop MOCKOBCKOro rocyap CTBeHHOro IOpHAMNeCKOFO yHNBePCNTeTa MM. O. E. KyTa(MHa
(MFFOA) (r. MOCKBa, Poccwn)
XwcaMOBa 3. 1., KaHAMgaT 1OpMgMANCKMX HayK, Ha~aJ1bHMK OTgejleHMFI F1Ja HPMOBaHMfI M KOOPAHI4mM HayHO AgefITelIbHOCTM
Hay4Ho-MCCleAoBaTenlbCKOro OTgella KpaCHOga PCKOro y HBePCNTeTa MMHMCTepCTBa BHyTpeHHMX Aeni POCCMCKO Oegepa4MM
(r. KpaCHOgap, PoccMsn)
Wa#wpoB B. M., AOKTOP IOpHAgMNCKMX HayK, npOjeccop CNM5pCKOFO egepallbHOro yHNBePCNTeTa (r. KpaCHOTpCK, PoccM)
UeCTaKOB A. A., AOKTOP IOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop POCCMkCKOro ocyga PCTBeHHOro negarorNeCKOro yHNBepCwTeTa MM. A. V. FepLjeHa,
npe3MAeHT CaHKT-leTep6yprCKOro Me>KAyHapOAHomo KPHMMHOIOFMNHCKOFO Knly6a, 3aCj1y>KeHHblM gelTeilb HayKM POCCMCKOM Oegepa4MM
(r. CaHKT-fleTep6ypr, PoccMsn)
WHLKeBH A. 1., AOKTOP 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, AOKTOp TeXHMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop Ka3aHCKoro HaI4MOHalJbHOFO MCCJleAOBaTelbCKOFO
TeXHOJiOFMNHCKOFO yHNBePCNTeTa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMsF)
3APYVENHbIE JI1EHbI PEAKOJ1EF14:
AnM Am., AOKTOP @MIOCO@MM B 06laCTM 3KOHOMMKM, npOc eccop 3KOHOMMKM Tynle HCKOro yHNBePCNTeTa (F. HOBbl Op/leaH, CWA)
AnOcTanaKwc A., AOKTOP @MIOCO@MM B 06laCTM 3KOHOMMKM, npOc eccop [peNeCKMA CpeAM3eMHOMOpCKMM yHMBePCMTeT (F. VpaKAiMOH, [pe4Ml)
Ua66ap Am., AOKTOP @MIOCO@MM B o61laCTM 3KOHOMMKM, npO eccop YHMBepCMTeTa F. lOpTCMyT (F. flOpTCMyT, BejiMKO6pMTaHMF)
KaMeHKOB B. C., AOKTOP 1OpMgMANCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop, 3aCjy>KeHHblM IOpMCT Pecny6j1MKM Belapycb, 3aBegypOLLAM Ka egpoM
BelnopyCCKOro FOCygaPCTBeHHOFO yHNBePCNTeTa (F. MMHCK, Pecny6jnMKa Benapycb)
KypH X., AOKTOP ICMXO/IOFMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop OpaM6yprCKOro yHNBepCwTeTa (r. OpaM5ypr, [epMaHMI)
MeKO r., npocjeccop, PyKOBOAMTeJ1b HHCTMTyTa yFOjiOBHOFO npaBOCygHI M 6e30naCHOCTM B FC]S YHMBepCMTeTa B MapM60pe;
npe3MAeHT EBponekCKoM aCCOI4MaI4MM KPHMMHOIOFOB (ESC) (r. MapM60p, CJ1oBeHMB)
Py6MH 3. I., npo eccop npaea M fOJiMTOJ1OFMM lKOnbl npaea YHMBepCMTeTa BaHAep6MnjbTa (r. HeWBMJlJ, WT. TeHHeCCM, CWA)
CeppaHo-Maono A., npo eccop, 3aBegywoL4MH Ka egpoM yFOjiOBHOFO npaBa M KPMMMHOJ1OFM HaL4MOHanbHOro yHNBePCNTeTa
AMCTaH4MOHHOFO 06pa30BaHMA (r. MagpmA, VcnaHMN)
Type4K A H. H., AOKTOP IOpAMNgeCKMX HayK, npopeKTOp nO Hay4HOM pa5OTe AKageMMM npa BOOXpa H TeJlbHblX OpraHOB [eHepallbHO
npOKypaTypbl Pecny6jiiK Ka3aXCTaH, npegCegaTellb CoIo3a KPMMMHOJ1OFOB Ka3aXcaHa MM. E. KaMp>aHOBa (r. ACTaHa, Pecny6nMKa Ka3aXCTaH)
OApMYK A., AOKTOP COIMJalbHblX 3KOHOMMNHCKMX HayK, npOjeccop YHMBepCMTeTa 3enneIMH (r. OpApHXCXa eH, [epMaHMI)
>KypHan 3aperLCTpLpoBaH OegepanbHOHn
cnym6on no HaA30py B C4epe CB53L,
LH opMaL4HoHHbIXTeXHoorN I MaCCOBbIX
KOMMyHKa4N.
PerLcTpaL4LoHHbIN HOMep L AaTa 1pLHlTfl
peweHN.9 O perCTpaLL:
flH/ No $C77-81556 OT 27 LIOJW 2021 r.
TeppHTopI9 pacnpoCTpaHeH9:
POccLAcKaa $egepa4I5; 3apy6ewHble CTpaHbl
Y
$opMaT 60x84/8. Ycn. neH. n. 29,25. Thpaw 1000 3K3.
foInLmcaHO B e~aTEb 27.02.2023. 3aKa3 No 11.
AaTa BblXo0a B CBeT 27.03.2023.
L4eHa CBo6o0Hag.
@ HOY BO uKV/Y MM. B. . TMLp3COBa,
000 uT[40 uTar1IMaT», 2023.
OTne~aTaHO C rOTOBOrO OpLrLHaAi-MaKeTa
B Tnorpa( NL 000 uBecT anLIKa»:
420111, r. Ka3aHb, yn. MOCKOBCKa, 22
Y4pepMTenb -
HOY BO R Ka3aHCKINN
LIHHOBaL4LIOHHbIN
yHLBepCTeT LMeH
B. F.TMLp5ICOBa2
M3paTenb -
000 ((RTO (TarMINMaT
Appec peaK44M:
420111,
Pecny6nAKa TaTapCTaH,
r. Ka3aHb,
yn. MOCKOBCKaq, 42
Ten.: (843) 231-92-90,
OaKC: 292-61-59
E-mail: rusjel@ieml.ru
Ca T: rusjel.ru
>KypHan BK1O-4eH
B flepeeHb BAK
no CneL4LanbHOCTM:
5.2.1. 3KOHOMLeCKa
Teop mHq;
5.2.3. PerOHaJbHaS
N OTpaC1eBa 3KOHOMIKa;
5.1.4. YrOnIOBHO-npaBoBble
HayKN
MHreKCL pyeTCfl B HenOnline,
CyberLeninka, RePEc, DOAJ,
ProQuest
flAnMCKa Ha WKypH2
no 06beAHeHHOMy
KaTa/iory ( flpecca PocCnin
HaL MHeKC - 86303
OTBeTCTBeHHbIN 32 BbiflyCK:
F. S. ,QapH HOBa
PepaKTOp:
F. A. TapacoBa
KoMnbloTepHaf BepCTKa:
C. A. RapLMoBa
M32MAH 06aOwKn:
F. N. 3arpeTrA1HOBa
AL32NH JorOTna:
B. A. KpaKOB
flepeBOA4MK:
KaHA. neA. HayK,
iNleH F~bEIIM
nepe BOAiN'KOB PT
E. H. BeinleBa
AyMOKOHTeHT caTa:
000 rOniOC HayKn»
PeL4eH3LpoBaHLHe CTT B )ypHa/Je -ABONHoe clenoe.
flp L4NTpOBaHI MaTepHJlOB CCbIJ1Ka
Ha mypHa o693aTeflbHa.
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a L3j1OeHHble B CTaTb.X 4 aKTbl
HeCyT aBTOpbl. BbIcKa3aHHble B CTaTb.X MHeHflE
MOryT He COBlagaTb C TOYKON 3peHfl pegaKL4N
L He HanaraFoT Ha Hee HLKa KX 0633aTelbCTB.
S ' MaTepHianbl >ypHania AOCl/Hbl
no nLLH3LI Creative Commons Attribution License
(https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)](ViewImageLocal?handle=hein.journals/apel2023&div=1&collection=&method=preview&ext=.png&size=3)
What Is HeinOnline?
Contact us for annual subscription options:
Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?
profiles profiles most
Contact us for annual subscription options:
Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?
profiles profiles most
Contact us for annual subscription options:
Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?
profiles profiles most