About | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline Law Journal Library | HeinOnline

2022 Russ. J. Econ. & L. 1 (2022)

handle is hein.journals/apel2022 and id is 1 raw text is: Tom 16, N21
RUSSIAN OURNA               OF ECONOMCS AND LAW                           2022
D0I: 10.21202/2782-2923.2022.1

DOI: 10.21202/2782-2923
M3AaeTCs C FIHBapi 2007 roga, nepHOAH4HOCTb H3AaHHR - 4 pa3a B roA
PEAAKL4MOHHAA KOJIJIEFHB
naBHbIe pepaKTOpbl:
ELKeeB H. H., AOKTOp LopgHANeCKIX HayK, npO4)eccop, 3aCjiy>KeHHbl KOpLCT Pecny 6lMKM TaTapCTaH, fepBbl npopeKTOp, f0popeKTOp
nO HayHHO1 pa6oTe Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBa4LOHHOFO yHLBepCMTeTa MM. B. r. TMMMpICOBa (F. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
KneAHep F. 6., AOKTOp 3KOHOMLNeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop, HLueH-KoppecnOHAeHT POCCMECKON aageMNN HayK, 3aMeCTlTeJlb HayHHOFO
pyKOBOAMTJefIm LeHTpalbHOFO 3KoHoMMKO-MaTeMaTMNeCKOro MHCTHTyTa POCCMECKON aKageMMM HayK (r. MOCKBa, Poccwi)
THXOMwpOB K0. A., AOKTOp IOpwALNeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop HHCTMTyTa 3aKOHo aTeJlbCTBa M CpaBHMTelJbHOFO npaBOBegeHMfl
npm npaBMTelbCTBe POCCMECKON Oegepa4MM, 3aCjiy>KeHHbl1 AelTeilb HayKH POCCECKON OegepaMM (r. MOCKBa, Poccwi)
3aMecTwTenw rnaBHbIX pepaKTOpOB:
AHApIowH C. A., AOKTOp 3KOHOMLNeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop, FJlaBHbl1 HayHHbl1 COTpygHK HHCTMTyTa 3KOHOMMK POCCMECKON aKageMMM
HayK, KypaTOp HanpaBneHHA uMOHeTapHaA TeOpHIH L I4CpOBble 4IIaHCbI) (r. MOCKBa, Poccwi)
Ka6aHoB ni. A., AOKTOp IopwALNeCKMX HayK, npOc eccop, gAlpeKTOp HHH npOTMBOgeCTBMfI KOppyrl4MM Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBa4LOHHOFO
yHNBepCNTeTa MM. B. r. TMMMpHCOBa, KypaTOp HanpaBneHH IOpAmpeCKHX HayK (r. Ka3aHb, PoccHw)
KpaMMH T. B., AOKTOp 3KOHOMLNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop, gAlpeKTOp HHH npo6nleM co4lanabHo-3KoHOMMNeCKOro pa3BMTMFI pa3BMTMFI
Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBaI4LOHHOFO yHLBepCMTeTa MM. B. r. TMMMpICOBa, KypaTOp HanpaBneHH 3KoHOMMIeCKHX HayK (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
OTBeTCTBeHHbA ce KpeTapb:
FpwropbeB P. A., AOKTOp @MJ1OCO@MM B 06laCTM 3KOHOMMKM (BejiMKO6pMTaHMW), 3aMcCTMTelJb gApeKTOpa HVV npo6/leM
co4lanaIbHo-3KoHoMNeCKoro pa3BMTMNI Ka3aHCKOro MHHOBa4LOHHOFO yH BepCNTeTa MM. B. r. TMMMpT COBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
AHTOHOBa H. H., LAOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, AoI4eHT, nOpe KTOp nO MHHOBaI4MOHHO-npoeKTHOL fAeFiTelbHOCTM Ka3aHCKOro
MHHOBaI4MOHHOFO yHNBepCwTeTa MM. B. r. TMMMpICOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
EapaHoB B. M., AOKTOp IOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop, 3aCjiy>KeHHbl1 AelTeilb HayKM POCCMECKON Oegepa4MM, fOMO4IHMK Ha~aHIbHMKa
HMeropOACKO aKage~MN MBA PocCMM nO MHHOBaI4MOHHOMy pa3BMTMO (r. HMKHM HOBropoA, PoccMNs)
Eer~weB H. P., KaHfAgaT KOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, 3aCly>KeHHbl1 KOpMCT Pecny6IMKM TaTapCTaH, CTapwMw HayHHbl1 COTPYfHMK Ka3aHCKOro
MHHOBaI4MOHHOFO yHNBepCwTeTa MM. B. r. TMMMpICOBa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccwI)
BOnibHK B. B., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop IO>KHOFO  egepabHOro yHNBepCwTeTa (r. POCTOB-Ha-AOHy, PoccwI)
FMAIMHCKME .9. H., LAOKTOp IopHAMNeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop CaHKT-leTep6yprCKOro KOpHAMNeCKOFO MHCTMTYTa AKageMMM reHepallbHO
npOKypaTypbl POCCMECKON Oegepa4MM, POCCMECKOrr FOCygapCTBeHHOFO negarorNeCKOro yHNBepCNTeTa MM. A. V. FepLjeHa
(r. CaHKT-fleTep6ypr, PoccNi)
Fon HoeHKO 0. F., LAOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop L eHTpalbHOFO 3KoHoMMKO-MaTeMaTMNeCKOFo MHCTMTYTa POCCMCKON aKageMMM
HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccwN)
E4IMLM4eBa T. B., AOKTOp IOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop OpeH6yprCKOro MHCTMTYTa (#MnIMalla) MOCKOBCKOro rocygapCTBeHHOro
KOpwAMNeCKOFO yHBepCNTeTa MM. O. E. KyTa(MHa (MFFOA) (r. OpeH6ypr, PoccMsn)
Ka~anOB P. M., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop L eHTpalbHOFO 3KoHoMMKO-MaTeMaTMNeCKOFo MHCTMTYTa POCCMCKON aKageMMM
HayK (r. MOCKBa, PoccwN)
KopbITn4eB M. A., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop IO>KHOFO  egepabHOro yHNBepCNTeTa (r. POCTOB-Ha-AOHy, PoccwI)
KyppABt4eBa 0. B., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop MOCKOBCKOro rocyfapCTBeHHOro yHNBepCNTeTa MM. M. B. JlOMOHOCOBa
(r. MOCKBa, PoccwN)
Jla3apeB B. B., rlaB Hbl Hay4Hbl1 COTPYfHMK L e HTpa (y HAaMeHTaIbHbIX nlpaBOBbIX MCCJleAOBaHWM1 HHCTMTyTa 3aKOHOgaTeIbCTBa
M CpaBH MTeJbHOFO npa BOBegeHN npm n paBMTelnbCTBe POCCMCKON Oegepa4MM, AOKTOp IOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, npOcjeccop,
3aCJIy>KeHHbL AelTeilb HayKM POCCMECKON Oegepa4MM (r. MOCKBa, Poccwi)
JlaTOB K0. B., AOKTOp CO4MOJIOFMNeCKMX HayK, KaHAMgaT 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, BepyLML1 HayHHbl1 COTPYfHMK L eHTpa KOMflJeKCHbIX
co4malJbHblX MCCJleAOBaHM1 HHCTMTyTa CO4MOJiOFM POCCMECKON aKageMMM HayK (r. MOCKBa, Poccmi)
JILneIHb C. B., AOKTOp IOpHAMNeCKMX HayK, LOI4eHT MOCKOBCKOro rocyfapCTBeHHOo KopH MgNeCKOFO YHHBepCHTeTa MM. O. E. Kyra@MHa
(MnOA) (r. MOCKBa, PoccNi)
MaKaposa 0. A., AOKTOp IOpH MNeCKMX HayK, LOI4eHT Kac egpbl KOMMepHeCKOFO npaBa CaHKT-leTep6yprCKOro rocygapCTBeHHOro
yHHBepCHTera (r. CaHKT-fleTep6ypr, PoccNi)
HypeeB P. M., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop, r/laBa genapTaMeHTa 3KOHOMMNeCKO TeOpHM B OMHaHCOBOM yHHBepC TeTe
npH npaBMTenbcTBe PO (r. MOCKBa, PoccMNs)
TapaceHKO 0. A., AOKTOp IOpH MNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop MOCKOBCKOro rocyfapCTBeHHOo KopH MgNeCKOFO YHHBepCHTeTa MM. O. E. KyTa(MHa
(MFFOA) (r. MOCKBa, PoccMNs)
XwcaMOBa 3. H., KaHAMgaT KOpH MNeCKMX HayK, Ha~aIbHMK OTgejleHMfI flja1HMpOBaHMfI M KOOpMHaI4MM HayHHO1 fAeBFTelbHOCTM
Hay4Ho-MCCleAOBaTenlbCKOro OTgella KpaCHogapCKOro YHHBepCHTeTa MMHMCTepCTBa BHyTpeHHHXAen POCCHMCKON Oegepa4MM
(r. KpaCHOgap, PoccMNs)
WacrnpoB B. M., AOKTOp IOpH MNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop CHM5pCKOFO  egepabHOro YHHBepCHTeTa (r. KpaCHOTpCK, PoccMsF)
WeCTaKOB A. A., AOKTOp IOpH MNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop POCCHCKOro nocyarapCTBeHHOoo neparoEm~eCKOro YHHBepCHTeTa MM. A. V. FepLjeHa,
npe3MAeHT CaHKT-fleTep6yprCKOro Me>KAyHapOAHOFO KpHMMHOIOFMNeCKOFO Knly6a, 3aCly>KeHHbl1 AelTeilb HayKM POCCHMCKOI Oegepa4MM
(r. CaHKT-fleTep6ypr, PoccMNs)
WwHKeBH A. H., AOKTOp 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, LAOKTOp TeXHMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop Ka3aHCKoro HaI4MOHalJbHOFO MCCj1efOBaTelbCKOFO
TeXHOJiOFMHeCKOFO YHHBepCHTeTa (r. Ka3aHb, PoccMsF)
3APYVENHbIE HJ1EHbI PEAKOJIJIEFm:
AnM Am., AOKTOp @MJ1OCO@MM B 06laCTM 3KOHOMMKM, npOcjeccop 3KOHOMMKM TynIeNHCKOro YHHBepCHTeTa (r. HOBbl OpnleaH, CWA)
AnocranaKwc A., AOKTOp @MJ1OCO@MM B 06aCTM 3KOHOMMKM, npO eccop [pe~eCKM CpeM3eMHOMOpCKMH yHMBepCMTeT (r. HpaK iMOH, [peMA)
Ame44pH W., AOKTOp @MJ1OCO@MM B 06laCTM 3KOHOMMKM, npOcjeccop YHMBepCMTeTa F. nopTCMyT (r. nopTCMyT, BejiMKO6pHTaHMH)
KaMeHKOB B. C., AOKTOp IOpH MNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop, 3aCjiy>KeHHbl1 KOpHCT Pecny6jMKM Belapycb, 3aBegyOL4ML Ka epo
BenopycCKoro rocygapCTaeHHoro yHHBepCHTera (r. MMHCK, Pecny6jnMKa Benapycb)
KypH X., AOKTOp F1CMXOj1OFMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop OpaN6yprCKOro YHHBepCHTeTa (F. OpaN6ypr, [epMaHMB)
MewKO r., npocjeccop, pyKOBOAMTJeJb HHCTMTyTa yFOjiOBHOFO npaBOCygAMi M 6e30naCHOCTM B FCJS YHMBepCMTeTa B MapM60pe;
npe3MAeHT EBponekCKON aCCOI4MaI4MM KpHMMHOJIOFOB (ESC) (r. MapM60p, CJIOBeHMA)
Py6MH 3. 1., npo eccop npaBa M fOJ1MTOOFHM WKOJlbl npaBa YHMBepCMTeTa BaHgep6MnbTa (r. HeWBMJII, WT. TeHHeCCM, CWA)
CeppaHo-Maino A., npo eccop, 3aBegylOL4ML Ka egpo yFOjiOBHOFO npaBa M KpHMMHOIOFM Hal4MOHanbHOro YHHBepCHTeTa
fMCTaH4MOHHOFO 06pa30BaHMB (F. MagpHA, VcnaHM)
Type{KMA H. H., AOKTOp OpHMANMeCKMX HayK, npopeKTOp nO HayHHO pa5OTe AKageMMM npaBOOXpa HTeJlbHblX OpraHOB [eHepanbHO
npOKypaTypbl Pecny6jiiKH Ka3aXCTaH, npegCegaTellb CoIo3a KpHMMHOIOFOB Ka3aXCTaHa MM. E. KaMp>aHOBa (r. ACTaHa, Pecny6nMKa Ka3aXCTaH)
OwppMyK A., AOKTOp COI4MaJIbHbIX 3KOHOMMNeCKMX HayK, npOjeccop YHMBepCMTeTa 3enne/M H (r. OpH ApXCXa eH, [epMaHMB)

>KypHan 3aperHCTPHpoBaH OegepanbHOHn
cnym6on no HaA30py B crepe CB53H,
HH4 OpMaLAHOHHbIXTeXHoJIormN H MaCCOBbIX
KOMMyHHKaLgH .
PerHcTpaLAHOHHoe CBHAeTenbCTBo:
nfH No $C77-81556 OT 27 HwOJW 2021 r.
TeppHTopHE pacnpoCTpaHe H H:
PoccHNcKaA $egepa1H; 3apy6ewH ble CTpaH bl.

YVpeAwTenb -
HOY BO (Ka3aHCKMN
MHHOBaLWOHHbIN
YHMBepCMTeT MMeHM
B. F. TMMM pCOBan
13AaTenb -
000 (TL40 (TarmvMaTn
Aqpec peqaKl{H:
420111,
Pecny6MKa TaTapcTaH,
r. Ka3aHb,
ym. MOCKOBCKan, 42
Ten.: (843) 231-92-90,
Ca KC: 292-61-59
E-mail: apel@ieml.ru
Cai7T: rusjel.ru
)4ypHan BKAFOteH
B flepeleHb BAK no rpynne
cneLlanbHOCTe 08.00.00 -
3KOHOMVReCKMe HayKM
HHpeKCMpyeTCn B EBSCO,
ERICH PLUS, HeinOnline,
CyberLeninka, RePEc,
DOAJ, ProQuest
floqnCKa Ha )KYPHa
no 06bep HeHHOMy
KaTanory ((flpecca PoCCMMn
Haw IHAeKC - 86303
OTBeTCTBeHHbIA 3a BbinyCK:
F. 5. LAap'HHOBa
PeqaKTOp:
F. A. TapacOBa
KOMnbloTepHan BepCTKa:
C. A. KapMMOBa
JM13aHH 06nOWKw:
F. H. 3arpeTAMHOBa
JM13aHH JlorOTnla:
B. A. Kpai7KOB
flepeBOA4wK:
KaHA. nep. HayK,
wleH Fm.bpAHN
nepeBOAMKOB PT
E. H. BenneBa

9'                                                                                                 -

$OpMaT 60x84/8. YCn. ne4. n. 28. THpaw 1000 3K3.
foRnHcaHO B neHaTb 25.02.2022. 3aKa3 No 18
AaTa BblXofa B CBeT 30.03.2022
L4eHa CBo6oAHa
@ HOY BO uKVY HM. B. F. THMHpfCOBa>,
000 uT(40 uTarJ1MMaT», 2022
OTneHaTaHO C rOTOBOrO OpmrMHa1-MaKeTa
B THnorpaMAM 000 u(BecT aJ1KaM:
420111, r. Ka3aHb, yn. MocKOBCKaq, 22.

Pe LeH3HpoBaHHe CTT B )ypHale -
ABOH~oe Cnenoe.
fpH LHTHpOBaHHH MaTepmaHnOB CCblJIKa
Ha mypHa o693aTeflbHa.
OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a H3J1O>eHHble B CTaTb.DX 4 aKTbl
HeCYT aBTOpbl. BbIcKa3aHHble B CTaTb.X MHeHHf
MOryT He COBnagaTb C TOHKON 3peHH3 pegaKLHH
H He Hanara oT Ha Hee HHKaKHX 06393aTelbCTB.
MaTepHanbl wypHana AOCTylHbl
no J1H4eH3HH Creative Commons Attribution License
(http://creativecom mons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)

What Is HeinOnline?

HeinOnline is a subscription-based resource containing thousands of academic and legal journals from inception; complete coverage of government documents such as U.S. Statutes at Large, U.S. Code, Federal Register, Code of Federal Regulations, U.S. Reports, and much more. Documents are image-based, fully searchable PDFs with the authority of print combined with the accessibility of a user-friendly and powerful database. For more information, request a quote or trial for your organization below.



Short-term subscription options include 24 hours, 48 hours, or 1 week to HeinOnline.

Contact us for annual subscription options:

Already a HeinOnline Subscriber?

profiles profiles most